Dead Air · Season 3 · Sep 29, 2026 · 52 min

The Master Tapes That Walked Out the Door

EP 142 · Dead AirThe Master Tapes That Walked Out the Door
00:00 / 52:07
Show notes →

Show notes

In the spring of 1998, a box of twelve two-inch reels left a basement studio on Wythe Avenue. The session they held — an unreleased album by a band that broke up a month later — was presumed lost for two decades.

Then, in 2018, the tapes appeared in an online auction listed as “vintage studio tapes, unknown artist.” This week Maya traces the chain of custody: the studio owner, the tape op, a storage-unit buyer in Jersey City and a collector who still will not say what he paid.

In this episode

  • Why two-inch tape is the most valuable object in a 90s studio
  • The difference between owning a master and owning a song
  • How a forty-dollar bid became a federal lawsuit
  • What happened to the band — and the one member who agreed to talk
“A tape is just plastic and rust. Until somebody remembers what’s on it.”

Links & credits

Produced by Kim Ahn. Mixed at Loudhouse Studio B. Theme music by The Pale Hours. Archival audio courtesy of the Wythe Ave Studio log, used with permission.

Transcript

Read along

Auto-generated, then corrected by a human producer.

MAYA: The reels were in a banker’s box. Two-inch tape, twelve of them, labelled in grease pencil. Nobody remembers who carried them out.